“ The sauce is the best ever. Layers of flavor. We enjoyed the ample sized lasagna and "bar meatballs." The meatballs are near baseball sized smothered in sauce with grilled onions, green peppers and mushrooms then covered...really covered with cheese. Try the hot bacon dressing if you're having a salad. Great service. We almost drove away because the restaurant is in a neighborhood, not really business district. It is an older building. The dining area is quite nice and very comfortable. ”

“ Awesome find! We were in town for a swim meet and our kids wanted itialian. We really enjoyed all of the food. The portions were generous, and the prices were fair. The garlic bread with cheese appetizer was awesome! I am glad we took the time to find this resurant. ”

“ Staff was friendly in the phone. Restaurant was very busy when I arrived and all the customers seemed very happy. Everyone was eating pizza. This will be our next purchase. Had the chicken parm and spaghetti. It was amazing. The only complaint I have is there was not a lot of spaghetti. Sauce was very good. Cheesy garlic bread and the Italian bread was very good. Happy to find this place. The staff at the bar were great. ”

“ Visiting the area will definitely recommend Michael's. Thick cut bone in Pork Chops that melt in your mouth! Pizza & fried ravioli. Amber did a great job, very attentive patient & kind. ”

“ I've been going here since I was a baby. It's tradition to get a kiddie cocktail and the cheese and crackers. You should plan at least 2 hours for dinner time... Order the C&C, have a drink from the full bar, and just enjoy the atmosphere. This place has tons of history and if you're from Elkhart, it's likely you see someone you know. Don't be afraid of the neighborhood... There seems to be some unspoken respect for Michael's guests. Maybe I'm just naive . Anyways, go treat yourself. ”

“ Just tried Michael’s tonight. Carry out. Spectacular tasting food! Highly recommend the spaghetti and meatballs and the cheesy bread! The little bartender gal was so sweet and a little cutey! Can’t wait to try the dining next time! ”

“ Whoops! I forgot to take pictures. The evening was Excellent. Yes, it was crowded. However, that is a statement to how good this restaurant is and that people want to be there. We were celebrating a birthday and enjoyed a variety of dishes. I had the Veal Parmesan which comes on a serving of spaghetti with marinara sauce. Another of us had the Fat Tony - a pasta dish with pesto (along with vegetables). We had a small salad to accompany the main dishes. The Hot (warmed) Bacon dressing is Great. Hey! It's on a salad. The others shared a pizza and fried mushrooms appetizer. Everyone was very happy with their meals and definitely full. It is a split, but open (half wall) area that the dining area and bar share. Busy, but the wait Staff is very attentive to the customers and the turn over of customers leaving to clean tables for new customers is excellent. ”

“ We eat at Michaels at least twice a month. And it’s always the same great food and service whether it’s for lunch or dinner. And their hot bacon dressing is the best on any kind of salad. ”